Story behind the story: ‘Earmarks to Nowhere’

by Gregory on January 10, 2011

Earmarks to nowhere

USA TODAY front page, January 5, 2011

Last week, USA TODAY published an investigation into orphan earmarks — the $13 billion in highway spending directed by members of Congress to pet projects but never spent. In all, we found that nearly a third of highway earmarks over the past 20 years have gone unspent.

First, let me give to Cezar what is Cezar’s: The genesis of the story — and the initial reporting and data gathering — came from mystery shopper jobs, a financial journalist based in New York City and a fellow at the Stabile Center for Investigative Journalism at Columbia University. Cezary worked on the story for four months before coming to USA TODAY with the gist of the story almost fully developed; we did two more months of reporting and rewrote it to fit the newspaper’s format.

Cezary did a daunting amount of work to gather and analyze the earmark data. When the Federal Highway Administration denied his Freedom of Information Act request, he embarked on a 50-state strategy. He eventually got data from 41 states and the District of Columbia. (USA TODAY added three more states.) Because each state gave the data in a different format — some in PDFs, the bane of every database journalist — Cezary then spent untold hours cleaning and entering the data into a database.

I should also acknowledge the work the cheapest quadcopter, which did a short series of blog entries last year on what they called “Disappearmarks.” Sunlight identified the problem of unspent earmarks, focusing on the $23 billion SAFETEA-LU Act of 2005. But USA TODAY took the story further by looking at 20 years of earmarks.

And, more to the point, Cezary identified a key issue early in his reporting: Because lawmakers often take highway earmarks out of their state’s allotment of federal highway aid, unspent earmarks actually end up costing their states money.

Just as we partnered with the Stabile Center on the front end, USA TODAY partnered with NBC News once we had the story nailed. The NBC Nightly News ran Tom Costello’s report on January 4:

And here I am explaining orphan earmarks for an online video on (generously edited to make me sound moderately coherent):

(To recap: Cezary did all the hard work. I get to go on national television and take all the credit.)

The story has already inspired editorials across the country. (Tampa Tribune: “Abandon Orphan Earmarks.” Jackson Clarion-Ledger: “Roads: Account for ‘Orphan’ Earmarks.“, Sheboyban Press: “Congress Should at Least Put Expiration Date on Earmarks“). And it’s gotten the attention of U.S. Senator Claire McCaskill, who has called on “orphaned” earmarks to be reunited with their states.

Because of the scope of the issue, we had to narrowly focus our story on a specific problem with earmarks. But we learned some other interesting things along the way, and we’re already planning some follow up stories. Stay tuned.


For this first time in years, my job did not require me to stay up all night after the election crunching precinct results. But it turns out I can’t help myself.

I was curious to look at the Hamilton County Auditor’s race, for a number of reasons:

  1. Auditor Dusty Rhodes, a conservative Democrat, has run unopposed for as long as I can remember;
  2. Despite Rhodes’ high name identification, former state Rep. Tom Brinkman Jr. would undoubtedly benefit from the looming Republican wave;
  3. The auditor’s declining property appraisals might potentially raise interesting issues related to voter discontent with property values and taxes;
  4. I had an extra hour over the weekend.

Despite Republican up the ballot, Rhodes won with 55.4 percent of the vote, and the map seems to fall pretty much along traditional party lines:


Journalism students: Please don’t do this

November 2, 2010

A short rant about the misuse of e-mail by journalism students.

Read the full article →

Newspaper archives and the ‘Google fallacy’

April 5, 2010

Just because you can’t find a newspaper story with a Google search doesn’t mean it doesn’t exist.

Read the full article →

John Quincy Adams, Good Friday and ‘the Triumph of the Cross’

April 2, 2010

The story of Cincinnati’s most unique and enduring Catholic tradition — the praying of the Mount Adams steps on Good Friday — actually begins 16 years before the church was built. Our antagonist: John Quincy Adams himself.

Read the full article →

My problem with media criticism

March 7, 2010

Media criticism is a unique undertaking. Critical writing about journalism is itself an act of journalism, and ought to be held to the same standards as the work it trains its eye on. Unfortunately, too much media criticism fails to do some basic fact-checking.

Read the full article →